Princeton University professor Robert Wuthnow (@RobertWuthnow), author of the book The Left Behind: Decline and Rage in Rural America, joined Ana (@anamariecox) this week to talk about his research. He and Ana began by exploring common misconceptions of rural America, and how rural Americans often conceive of themselves. Robert found a common theme among people: “Living here, in this place, we have a responsibility to do what we can to be a good neighbor, be a good citizen.”
Although he often found a perceived sense of “we-ness” within rural communities, that dynamic broke down when people shared their true opinions about things like marriage equality or a woman’s right to choose. Although many people held similar beliefs, the group was much less homogenous than they may have thought.
Ana asked Robert about how the group dynamic can change, and he explained that the boundaries of the groups get complicated, because the divide between us and them is never as obvious as people may think it is: “Within the community, people that they knew, the Hispanic family that lived down the block, and maybe they didn’t know very well but were part of the community, and the Muslim family that had moved in, or the Korean family that had the local restaurant, it was a matter of people having to negotiate the boundaries of who was in and who was out.”
Ana also asked whether Robert had foreseen the rise of Donald Trump (spoiler alert: he didn’t). Yet, he wasn’t surprised that people in rural America supported a Republican, as it merely continued a pattern established by the anti-abortion movement. He then discussed and dismissed the hypothetical that anti-abortion voters would vote for Democrats if Roe v Wade is overturned: “I tend to think the divide has been deepened, not just attitudinally but structurally, thinking about gerrymandering, and thinking about some of the changes having to do with campaign finances and all that… I have to imagine that the divide is going to continue.”
Then, former Mayor of Minneapolis Betsy Hodges (@BetsyHodges) joined Ana to answer a listener question about allyship from Teresa, a listener who joined them on the line.
You can find Robert’s book here.
Thank you to our sponsors!
Visit thirdlove.com/friends for 15% off your first order.
Get clean ingredients, backed by science at ritual.com/friends.
Check out framebridge.com and use promo code FRIENDS for an additional 15% off your first order.
Head to sunbasket.com/friends to get $35 off your first order.
Got Mueller Madness? Join Ana Marie Cox and Rick Wilson as they get up from a fetal position and debrief the Mueller Report. They begin with a quick review of the day from the perspective of the White House and various media outlets. Afterwards they talk about what it will take to defeat Trump in 2020, and which candidates they think can make it in this reality tv-esque election cycle. Turn off that NPR coverage and tune in.
This week host Ana Marie Cox is joined by Kathleen Hall Jamieson and Jay Rosen to talk about why scrolling down your news feed has become such a painful and depressing chore. Kathleen Hall Jamieson breaks down the rise of cynicism in the last 25 years and what the American media consumer can do to turn things around. Later, Jay Rosen joins Ana to talk about why political journalists need to stop trying to outsmart each other constantly.
Need some advice on how to deal with that one uncle who brings up the Birther Conspiracy at every family gathering? This week journalist Eli Saslow joins host Ana Marie Cox to discuss to radicalization of older people.
Nausheena Hussain and Beth Gendler join Ana Marie Cox to remind us that asking invasive questions requires a strong relationship, and that the internet is free! Nausheena and Beth discuss how their relationship formed over a common interest in stopping gun violence, and grew into a solidarity movement known as Muslim-Jewish Women on Minnesota. Afterwards they explore how White privilege affects not just their friendship, but the way that they show up for each other and how a typical meeting looks.
Ana Marie Cox is joined this week by Nina Burleigh who is Newsweek’s national politics editor. She wrote the book “Golden Handcuffs: The Secret History of Trump's Women” which picks apart systematic and generational issues within America’s Worst Family. Who is complicit and who is a casualty and who is a criminal and who is capitalism made manifest? Spoiler: it’s less of a straight answer than a Venn diagram.